Are current pharmaceuticals levels in natural waterways dangerous?
Are current pharmaceuticals levels in natural waterways dangerous?
Hello everyone,
If you had a look in my bathroom cabinet you would find a whole range of medicines I have accumulated over the years. Most households will have a cupboard or drawer somewhere with a range of painkillers and pills. Until recently, I had not considered what happens to these products once we have used them or thrown them out, and I was surprised to discover that many pharmaceutical chemicals end up in natural waterways.
There is a growing concern that pharmaceuticals, the chemicals found in medicines and drugs, are leaching into rivers, streams and lakes and harming aquatic life. To find out if these pharmaceuticals pose a problem, we asked 4 experts in toxicology and environmental sciences “Are current pharmaceuticals levels in natural waterways dangerous?”. 3 of the experts answered ‘likely’, here is what we found out…
Each month we investigate a topic voted by the community by asking the world's top experts to review the evidence. Please vote on which topic you would like us to review next month here:
EXPERT CONSENSUS
Are current pharmaceuticals levels in natural waterways dangerous?
‘Likely’ or ‘near certain’ according to 3 out of 4 experts
What is the current level of pharmaceuticals in our natural waterways?
A USA study found measurable amounts of pharmaceuticals in 80% of the water samples they collected from streams across 30 different states. The issue of drugs in natural waterways is not just in the USA but across the globe. A 2014 review of over 1000 studies found pharmaceuticals residues in 71 countries worldwide.
The 2014 review found over 600 different pharmaceutical chemicals in lakes, rivers and ground water globally. These chemicals included antibiotics, painkillers, beta-blockers, contraceptive hormones and antidepressants, amongst others.
How do pharmaceuticals get into natural waterways?
There are a variety of ways that medicines and drugs end up in streams, rivers, and lakes. One of these ways is through sewage. When we take medications, we only absorb a fraction of the chemicals into our bodies, the rest is excreted out. Improperly disposing of medications by flushing them down the toilet also adds to this.
Pharmaceuticals can also leach into natural waterways from agriculture, where drugs, particularly antibiotics and hormones, are used for rearing livestock. Finally, pharmaceutical chemicals can also be released from industrial plants that make medications. For example, a wastewater treatment plant that is close to many pharmaceutical factories in India was found to have very high levels of some antibiotics.
Although waste water is cleaned in sewage treatment plants, Dr Bruno Nunes, an expert in toxicology from Aveiro University, says “water treatment processes are not effective to prevent [pharmaceutical] release into the aquatic ecosystem.”
What effect does this have on aquatic life?
It is difficult to know the full extent of how these pharmaceuticals affect aquatic life due to lack of data. However, there are some examples where drug contaminants have had toxic effects on wildlife. For example, the anti-inflammatory medication diclofenac, has been found in natural waterways and can damage renal and gastrointestinal tissues in fish which can kill them.
It is not always possible to predict the effect of pharmaceuticals in the environment based on experiments from the laboratory. Dr Nunes explains that this is because “Some of these drugs may interact with other substances and show some potential to compromise physiological traits of many aquatic species, even in the levels in which these substances occur.”
Pharmaceuticals also act in more indirect ways to damage aquatic life. Dr Mike Grace, an expert in environmental science from Monash University, says that current pharmaceutical levels are dangerous as they act “as a mechanism for inducing sub-lethal effects in stream organisms and essential ecosystem services like photosynthesis and nutrient cycling”.
Dr Grace explains that “pharmaceuticals at concentrations found in most waterways around the world are termed 'Ecosystem Disruptors'”. Estrogen pharmaceuticals have been shown to be ecosystem disrupters by feminizing male fish of certain species. This disrupts the male to female ratio of the fish and causes collapse of populations.
Is there any risk to humans?
Dr Grace says that current pharmaceutical levels in natural waterways are not dangerous to “humans touching the water” or “drinking a few mouthfuls”. Currently, the level of pharmaceuticals in drinking water is far below the concentration required for any physiological effect.
The takeaway:
Current pharmaceutical levels in natural waterways are dangerous for aquatic life, but pose no current threat to humans.
May the facts be with you!
Eva
METAFACT REVIEW
Can you prevent headaches?
Exclusive reviews for our fact-loving members.
Each month we investigate a topic voted by the community by asking the world's top experts to review the evidence. Reviews are what you need to know. You can read all the reviews online here.
As many as half of the world's adults have had a headache at some point last year. Some have them nearly every day. They can be very painful and debilitating, and a lot of research is being done on them.This month we asked scientists and clinicians to share the facts on all things Headaches. Are they in our minds, or is it all about brain chemistry? Can fatigue or poor sleep cause headaches? Can we prevent them? And how can we treat them? This science-backed guide will help you understand headaches without giving you one. Here's what we found...